Sweet and Spicy Bread-and-Butter Pickles

You'll want to put these crunchy, zesty pickles on everything.

Jars of pickled vegetables on a surface one jar is open
Credit:

Jacob Fox

Prep Time:
40 mins
Cook Time:
30 mins
Total Time:
4 hrs 10 mins
Servings:
32
Yield:
8 cups

You’ll want to put these sweet and spicy pickles on every burger and sandwich you make this summer. They have a classic bread-and-butter flavor profile that’s heightened by a generous amount of red pepper flakes, giving them a zesty kick that’s hard to resist. Making them couldn’t be easier; just allow a few hands-off hours for the cucumbers to firm up in the fridge. Then you'll need to decide how to use them—we love these pickles on cheeseburgers, tucked into turkey sandwiches, and chopped up in tuna and egg salad. Store them in the refrigerator for a couple of weeks, or can them following the steps in the recipe. This will preserve them for longer, so you can enjoy them throughout the year.

Why Salt Cucumbers Before Pickling

Salting and draining the cucumbers are key parts of the bread-and-butter pickle-making process. This essential step draws moisture from the flesh, resulting in a firmer, crispier pickle and a less watery brine. We also add ice, which causes the cucumbers' cell walls to contract and enhances the crunch.

Canning 101

The Process

Water-bath canning utilizes high heat to accomplish two goals: kill harmful bacteria, organisms, and mold; and force air out of the jars to form a secure seal, allowing them to be stored at room temperature. It can only be used with high-acid foods like pickles, tomatoes, and certain fruit preserves.

The process is simple: Jars are sterilized, then filled with pickles, with enough headspace left for the liquid to expand when heated. Next, they're boiled in a pot of hot water for 10 minutes, then are removed and left to cool so the seal can form.

Equipment Needs

Jars and lids: You'll need four pint jars with lids and screw tops for this recipe. Be sure that the jars are free of nicks and cracks, and the lids aren't dented or rusted.

Large pot with lid: Reach for a large, deep pot with a matching lid. It should be large enough to comfortably hold the pint jars with a few inches of space at the top.

Rack: To keep the jars from rattling around on the bottom of the pot, they should be elevated using a canning rack. If you don't have one, use a round metal cooling rack instead.

Jar lifters or tongs: Jar lifters are specialized tongs designed to keep jars from slipping as they're lifted in and out of the water. You can create a similar tool by wrapping a few rubber bands around the ends of your tongs to provide some grip.

How to Sterilize Jars

To sterilize canning jars, submerge them in boiling water for at least 10 minutes until they are ready to be filled. Jars can be reused, but the lids should be new and sterilized according to the manufacturer's instructions. For complete instructions, refer to the U.S. Department of Agriculture's canning guidelines.

Checking the Seal

Jars that have successfully sealed will have a concave lid that won't pop back up when pressed. You can also check the seal by removing the ring and carefully lifting the jar up by the lid. Note that it can take between 12 and 24 hours for the seal to form.

  • If a seal doesn't form within 24 hours, the pickles can still be eaten, but the jar must be stored in the refrigerator.

Directions

Ingredients for bread and butter pickles cucumbers onion sugar vinegar spices and ice

Jacob Fox

  1. Toss cucumbers and onion with salt and ice:

    To draw out excess liquid and increase crunch, toss cucumbers and onion with salt in a large colander. Add ice, and toss again. Place over a bowl, and refrigerate, tossing occasionally, for 3 hours. Drain. Rinse well, and drain again.

    Sliced cucumbers and onions in a colander with ice cubes

    Jacob Fox

  2. Make brine:

    Bring vinegar, sugar, mustard and celery seeds, peppercorns, turmeric, and red-pepper flakes to a boil in a saucepan. Add cucumbers and onion. Return to a boil.

    A pot on a stove with sliced cucumbers and onions being poured into it from a colander with a wooden spoon

    Jacob Fox

    Sliced cucumbers in a pot on a stovetop

    Jacob Fox

  3. Transfer pickles to jars:

    Ladle into 4 hot sterilized pint jars, leaving about 1/2 inch below each jar's neck. Wipe rims of jars with a clean, damp cloth; cover tightly with sterilized lids and screw tops.

    Jars of pickles being filled with a ladle from a pot

    Jacob Fox

    When securing on the screw tops, twist them just until they're "fingertip tight." This means using your thumb and fingertips and stopping when you feel resistance. A lid that's too tight will not allow air to vent out, while a lid that's too loose can the brine to leak out.

  4. Place jars in canning pot:

    Using tongs or a jar clamp, transfer jars to a rack in a large canning pot or a large, deep pot filled with hot water, being sure to keep jars upright at all times. (Jars should be spaced 1 inch apart, and should not touch sides of pot.)

    Using a jar lifter to place a jar of pickles into or remove it from a canning pot filled with water

    Jacob Fox

  5. Process jars:

    Cover with water by 1 inch. Cover pot, and bring to a boil. Process jars in boiling water for 10 minutes. Let cool. Press down on each lid. If lid pops back, it's not sealed; refrigerate unsealed jars immediately, and use within 1 month.

    Jars sealed and submerged in a pot for water bath canning

    Jacob Fox

    Canning jars covered in water inside a pot

    Jacob Fox

How to Store Pickles

Sealed jars can be stored in a cool, dark place for up to 1 year. Discard any jars that show signs of spoilage (including mold, rising bubbles, or an off smell) or a compromised seal.

Variation: Summer Squash Pickles

To make squash pickles, swap in an equal weight of summer squash for the cucumbers. Follow the recipe as written, but do not bring the brine back to a boil after adding the squash in step 2; instead, promptly remove the pot from the heat and proceed to step 3.

5 More Preserving Recipes to Try

Updated by
Esther Reynolds
Headshot of Esther Reynolds
Esther Reynolds is an experienced recipe developer, recipe tester, food editor, and writer with over a decade of experience in the food and media industries.

Related Articles