Classic Caesar Salad

(157)

Buttery croutons and a bold-yet-balanced dressing make for one stellar salad.

Classic Caesar Salad Video
1:58
Prep Time:
20 mins
Cook Time:
10 mins
Total Time:
30 mins
Servings:
6

You should make our classic Caesar salad recipe. It produces a crisp, creamy, and garlicky dish that's hard to resist. Anchovies, garlic, and egg yolk are whisked together directly in the salad bowl to form the base of the dressing, just how the original version was first prepared in 1924. Worcestershire sauce, Dijon mustard, and lemon juice bring savory, tangy, and bright notes, making for a punchy yet balanced coating for ultra-refreshing romaine lettuce. Buttery, peppery croutons finish the dish off, adding yet another touch that sets this Caesar apart from all others. Serve it as a starter or top it with poached chicken or seared shrimp for a meal on its own.

Two plates of Caesar salad with croutons served on a light surface with forks

Carson Downing

The 4 Components of a Perfect Caesar Salad

Lettuce: Crisp and sturdy, romaine lettuce leaves remain the go-to greens for a Caesar. When prepping them, trim off any limp or wilted parts, along with the very bottom of each head. Rinse well, then dry completely—excess moisture on the leaves will cause the dressing to slip right off and make a soggy salad.

Dressing: For our classic Caesar dressing, you'll begin by mashing anchovies and garlic into a paste, then add the Worcestershire, lemon juice, mustard, pepper, and egg yolk, whisking with a fork until well blended. Stream in the oil while whisking until the dressing is creamy and emulsified. There's no cheese in the dressing itself—it's tossed with the greens and croutons before serving.

Croutons: Buttery and piquant, our croutons feature two sources of heat: cayenne and black pepper (freshly ground, of course). Start them before prepping your greens and making the dressing to ensure they have time to cool before they are added to the salad.

Cheese: You'll need a full cup of grated or shaved cheese for this recipe. Using Parmesan will make for a nuttier, more mild flavor while pecorino Romano will lend a sharper, saltier finish.

Raw eggs should not be used in food prepared for babies, young children, or anyone who is pregnant or whose health is compromised. Instead, substitute 1 tablespoon store-bought mayonnaise for the egg yolk.

Why You Need to Use a Wooden Salad Bowl

Like some other classic Caesar salad recipes, ours calls for preparing the dish directly in a large wooden bowl. There are a few reasons for this:

  • The finish of the bowl makes mashing the anchovies and garlic easier than it would be in a glass or stainless-steel bowl.
  • Wood is also non-reactive, so there's no concern about it interacting with the acidic lemon juice.
  • As an added bonus, building the salad in the serving bowl cuts down on dirty dishes.

If you don't have a wooden bowl, simply make the Caesar in your go-to salad bowl. It will taste just as good.

Directions

Ingredients laid out for making a Classic Caesar Salad

Carson Downing

  1. Preheat oven; toss bread in oil mixture and season:

    Preheat oven to 450°F. Combine butter and olive oil in large bowl. Add cubes of bread, and toss until coated. Sprinkle with salt, cayenne pepper, and black pepper; toss until evenly coated.

    Cubed bread in a glass bowl likely prepared as croutons for a Caesar salad

    Carson Downing

  2. Bake croutons:

    Spread bread in a single layer on a 12-by-17-inch baking sheet. Bake until croutons are golden, about 10 minutes. Set aside.

    Cubed bread on a baking sheet prepared for making croutons or similar use

    Carson Downing

  3. Mash garlic and anchovies; mix dressing:

    Place garlic, anchovy fillets, and salt in a wooden salad bowl. Using two dinner forks, mash garlic and anchovies into a paste. Using one fork, whisk in pepper, lemon juice, Worcestershire sauce, mustard, and egg yolk. Whisk in olive oil.

    Empty wooden salad bowl with two forks and bits of dressing and food remnants at the bottom

    Carson Downing

    Whisking ingredients in a wooden bowl preparing Caesar salad dressing

    Carson Downing

    Mixing salad dressing in a wooden bowl pouring oil and whisking

    Carson Downing

  4. Chop romaine and toss salad:

    Chop the romaine leaves into 1- to 1 1/2-inch pieces. Add the croutons, romaine, and cheese to the bowl, and toss well. If you wish, grate extra cheese over the top. Serve immediately.

    Someone mixing a bowl of Caesar salad with tongs

    Carson Downing

Storing Leftover Salad

This salad is best enjoyed the day it's made and will begin to wilt after a few hours. You can refrigerate it to enjoy later in the day but it won't hold much longer than that.

What to Serve With Caesar Salad

This crisp, hearty salad makes the perfect starter for so many entrees. Pasta is a natural fit, such as our ultimate lasagna with meat sauce, this light and bright linguine with shrimp and white wine, or this simple-yet-satisfying homemade gnocchi with tomato sauce.

Like a classic wedge, Caesar salad is an ubiquitous offering at steak houses. To bring that vibe home, consider our recipe for flat-iron steak au poivre or, for a real splurge, try Martha's seared porterhouse steak (and don't forget the compound butter).

If you'd rather keep it a bit lighter, there's always braised fish with tomatoes, this whole roasted cauliflower with a tangy herb sauce, or these drunken mussels with chorizo and white beans.

Frequently Asked Questions

  • Where did the Caesar salad originate?

    The Caesar salad originated in Tijuana, Mexico in 1924. As the story goes, it was created by restauranteur Caesar Cardini during a busy Fourth of July weekend to satisfy guests when the kitchen ran low on usual menu items. His original recipe called for an egg yolk, garlic, Parmesan cheese, and Worcestershire sauce; anchovies were added later.


  • Can a different lettuce be used to make Caesar salad?

    While a different lettuce can technically be used to make Caesar salad, we recommend sticking with romaine. Sturdy, crunchy, and refreshing, it holds its own when tossed with the thick dressing and won't wilt like other greens would. In a pinch, kale is a good substitute and can be used instead.


  • Can this recipe be made vegetarian?

    Yes, this recipe can be made vegetarian. To do so, omit the anchovies and use vegan Worcestershire sauce. Note that it will be a bit less savory than the original version, and you may want to adjust the other ingredient amounts—specifically the Worcestershire and mustard—to round out the flavor.

5 More Sensational Salad Recipes to Try

Related Articles