9 Thrift Store Finds That Make Winter Entertaining Feel Extra Cozy

Table Linens

From tablecloths to runners, the thrift store is home to a plethora of table linens. These set the stage for a beautiful spread, whether you’re hosting a simple brunch or having friends over for a gourmet dinner.

"You’ll often find better quality [vintage pieces] compared to new purchases, and at a fraction of the cost," says Mackenzie Biehl, hosting expert. "Skip the stiff ironing; soft, lived-in linen feels more inviting and luxe."

Woven Baskets

Baskets are a given at most thrift stores, so comb through the selection to see if anything stands out. "I’m always so amazed by the abundance, no matter where I go, so you’re sure to find some that you love," says Anna Lisa Dobbs, an interior designer and antique collector.

"A woven basket is so versatile," she says. "For example, at a dinner party, laying a linen napkin inside the basket and wrapping bread has such a homestead warmth to it." Larger baskets are great for storing cozy throws.

Candle Holders and Lanterns

Overhead lights can kill coziness. When in doubt, go for soft, layered lighting. The thrift store can help with this via candle holders and lanterns.

Biehl prefers ceramic candleholders in warm neutrals—brass is pretty, too—and notes that lanterns are a welcoming touch at the entryway or around outdoor spaces. She suggests grouping candles and lanterns in odd-numbered clusters to create layered light.

Floor and Table Lamps

Speaking of mood-setting, ambient lighting, and interior design, Chalon Clark of Design Redefined says lamps are among the best things to buy secondhand. "The vintage bases are often far more sculptural, substantial, and interesting than what you’ll find new today," Clark says. "Older lamps were made with heavier materials, like ceramic, brass, stone, wood, and have a sense of craftsmanship that instantly elevates a room." 

For a quick update, swap in a new linen or paper shade. A small lamp in the bathroom or in the kitchen, or a floor lamp at the end of a couch or in a dark corner, instantly adds a cozy touch.

Mixed Glassware

Random glassware sets are commonly overlooked at thrift stores, but Dobbs says not write them off so quickly. “People will donate uneven sets, but that’s what makes it fun and unique. Build a collection of mixed glasses for hosting,” she says.

For a through-line, she recommends sticking to a similar style. “For me, I honed in on all etched footed glasses in various sizes. Even though they are all a little different, they still feel intentional and stylized.”

Punch Bowls

Hearkening back to Grandma’s day, a party punch is officially back in style. And the perfect way to showcase your signature drink is in a gorgeous punch bowl with some historical weight.

Biehl says, “Don’t save punch bowls for big parties. Use them for mulled wine, sangria, batched cocktails, or even sparkling water with citrus and herbs during smaller gatherings.”  

Antique Silver

Dobbs says you can embrace the natural patina of aged silver or polish it with a brush or rag. "I will never walk out of a thrift shop without hunting for a silver tray," she says. "I love using them as serving platters for a grazing table when hosting."

Neutral Servingware

Along with silver, Clark recommends scooping up neutral, earthy pieces that’ll add some warmth and atmosphere to your upcoming gatherings. Think solid wood bowls, marble trays, and brass accents. She says, “You can usually find trays, bowls, and serving utensils at a fraction of the cost of new, while getting a richer, more timeless look.” 

Vintage Mirrors

Thrift stores are full of small vintage mirrors, which can instantly create light and depth. "These are so underused in entertaining," Biehl says. "For example, you can use one as a reflective cocktail station that makes drinks look like they’re glowing."

"Place it on the counter or bar with a bottle of whiskey or champagne, a carafe of water, maybe a stack of citrus and herbs," she suggests. You can also use one as a part of your dining table centerpiece, or on a coffee table with some candles.