6 Kitchen Items Thrift Stores May Not Accept

A kitchen blender placed on a counter in a home kitchen setting with various items like green apples and a drinking glass nearby — Credit:
Getty Images

While sorting through belongings and creating donation piles, it's easy to assume that thrift stores will take everything you have to give—but that's not the case. This applies to all kinds of household and personal items, but even more surprisingly, it also includes kitchen items. It's less about sanitation and more about liability and uncertainty when it comes to these pieces. During the donation process, it's difficult for stores to guarantee that an item will function properly or safely once it leaves the shop.

Cleanliness also plays a role in these decisions because it's hard to confirm whether an item has been fully sanitized, and taking those extra steps can be time-consuming. In addition, many essential kitchen items originally come with warranties, which are typically no longer valid once donated—leaving no safety net for the customer if something fails.

To find out which kitchen items are most likely to be declined, we spoke with an expert on what items you should think twice about before dropping off at your local thrift store.

Daniel Rodriguez, director of operations at Housing Works Thrift Shops

What to Do With Unwanted Kitchen Items

According to Rodriguez, scrap metal yards and specialized electronics recyclers are great options for kitchen items with components. "For items that are still usable, local soup kitchens or community organizations can sometimes point you in the right direction," he adds. "And honestly, if you know someone who needs it, that direct pass-along is often the best outcome."

01 of 06

Tupperware

A cabinet shelf with neatly stacked plastic food containers and lids — Getty Images

Plastic Tupperware that looks overused—showing stains from food or oils or warped from heat exposure—is usually not resellable, Rodriguez says. Signs of heavy use and wear make the items look undesirable, and if accepted and placed on the sales floor, they often won't sell, making them a waste of shelf space.

The best rule to follow when donating items is to think about whether you would pick them up and buy them based on their condition.

02 of 06

Nonstick Cookware

Stack of various frying pans made from cast iron, carbon steel, non-stick coated and stainless steel, choosing the right kitchen ware, light gray background, copy space, selected focus — Getty Images

Nonstick cookware is not a timeless piece, and its quality often doesn't last. Other valuable cookware, such as cast-iron skillets and brands like Le Creuset, are accepted as long as they're in good, clean condition, Rodriguez says. If you're getting rid of scratched nonstick cookware, odds are, someone else wouldn't want to cook with it either.

03 of 06

Knives

While your kitchen knife set may work perfectly fine, it's not an item that thrift stores will often accept. If it's in good condition and you're upgrading, consider giving your old set of knives to a friend or family member who could use them.

Blenders

A countertop blender with a glass jar and stainless steel base on a kitchen counter — Getty Images

Because it's an electronic device, thrift stores will often reject the donation. Unless it's brand new, still in the box, or truly looks "like new" with all the original packaging and product information included, Rodriguez suggests scrapping it at a metal yard or gifting it to a friend or family member who needs one.

05 of 06

Toasters and Toaster Ovens

Similar to blenders, toaster ovens and toasters should be brand new, still in the box, or "like new" with all the original packaging and product information to resell at a thrift store. While it might work just fine, it's hard to know for sure once the customer leaves the store, and there are no active warranties to protect them if it stops working.

06 of 06

Microwaves

Modern Microwave in kitchen cupboard — Thapakorn Rujipak / GETTY IMAGES

Reselling microwaves is another challenge—this essential small kitchen appliance often doesn't make it onto the sales floor. If you can't find another home for it after upgrading to a new one, take it to a metal scrap yard to properly dispose of it, Rodriguez says.