4 Kinds of Books You Should Always Buy at the Thrift Store (Before Someone Else Does)

One thing is for certain: The thrift store is always full of surprises, and the book section is no exception. Sure, you’ll likely find outdated renditions of magazines (looking at you, TV Guide from 1997) and books with the cover completely torn off, but if you look closely, you’ll also find some real gems.

With such a large selection, it can be difficult to know what’s worth picking up. Luckily, we consulted with two experts for advice, who revealed the four types of books that are always worth grabbing—and why.

Vintage Cookbooks

If you've ever flipped through a midcentury cookbook, you know just how charming the illustrations and recipes can be. 

"Vintage cookbooks are consistently collectible, not just for the recipes but for the way they capture moments in time," says Barker. "I love getting a peek at how people cooked, hosted, and entertained across different eras and cultures."

Richter enjoys the personal touches found in old cookbooks. "I like to buy thrifted cookbooks because they usually get all smudgy and grease-stained in my kitchen," she says. "Plus, I like to see if there’s any existing marginalia from previous owners."

Those handwritten annotations add personality to a cookbook that you definitely can’t get from Amazon (and you might just learn a new trick in the kitchen while you’re at it).

First Editions

Richter loves first editions of "significant novels and culturally important works." However, she explains that identifying a book like this can be quite tricky, especially if you’re at a regular thrift store. For example, library editions of The Catcher in Rye can go for anywhere from $35 to $400, while a true first edition, first issue dust jacket copy in fine condition can cost $15,000, Richter notes.

She also cautions that the book-selling (and buying) market is fickle, and tastes can change with time, so it's important to do your homework. Research what distinguishes a true first edition from later printings, and don’t assume that every old book on the shelf is always going to be valuable.

Don't Miss

I'm a Professional Thrift Shopper—These Are the Items I Always Add to My Cart

7 Hidden Gems Worth Hunting for at the Thrift Shop

High-Quality Editions

Not every valuable book has to be rare. Sometimes, the craftsmanship of the book makes it worth keeping (especially if you’re looking for things that’ll look good on your shelf). "Linen covers, embossed spines, thick paper, and sewn bindings are all good signs of quality printing," Barker explains. "I also look for first editions, original dust jackets, or special publisher markings—small details that often turn a beautiful old book into a collectible one."

Art Books

Finally, don’t skip out on art or photography books. "Out-of-print art and photography books, and anything with a strong visual element tend to hold their appeal," Barker says. The rich images, quality paper, and eye-catching covers make them great candidates for coffee table books (and you don’t have to spend an arm and a leg for them).